Skip to main content

Table 1 Characteristics of studies included in the systematic review

From: Reliability of ultrasound versus digital vaginal examination in detecting cervical dilatation during labor: a diagnostic test accuracy systematic review

Study

Location

Study type

Sample size

Parity

Age median (range)/mean ± SD

Gestational age (weeks): median (range)/mean ± SD

BMI: kg/m2 median (range)/mean (SD)

Single or multiple

Presentation

Intervention

Control

Nulliparous

Multi

Cuerva et al. [25]

Spain

Prospective cohort

57

31.5%

68.5%

31.6 ± 6.3

39.2 ± 0.9

24.3 ± 5.4

Singleton

Cephalic

TPUS

DVE

Kim et al. [7]

South Korea

Prospective cohort

25

72%

28%

32 (18–38)

38.4 (32.8 -40.8)

Singleton

Cephalic

TPUS

DVE

Wiafe et al. [3]

Republic of Ghana

Prospective cohort

195

Nulli

Primi

31%

27 Mean

39 ± 4

28 (20–42)

Singleton

Cephalic

TPUS

DVE

47%

22%

Wilkinson et al. [24]

UK

Prospective cohort

195

93%

7%

31 (18–44)

40 (24–42)

24.1 (15.7–42.4)

Singleton

Cephalic

TPUS

DVE

Dimassi et al. [26]

Tunisia

Prospective cohort

60

   

Not mention

Not mention

Singleton

Cephalic

TPUS

DVE

Yuce et al. [28]

Turkey

Prospective cohort

43

58%

42%

   

Singleton

Cephalic

TPUS

DVE

Benediktsdotti et al. [27]

Sweden

Prospective cohort

86

Median (range): 1 (0–5)

30.5 (23–43)

40 (36–42)

24.3 (18–36)

Singleton

Cephalic

TPUS

DVE

Hassan et al. [12]

UK

Prospective cohort

52

Median(range): 0 (0–2)

34 (21–41)

40 (37–41)

29 (22–47)

Singleton

Cephalic

TPUS

DVE

Hassan et al. [13]

UK

Prospective cohort

40

100%

Not mentioned

Not mentioned

Not mention

Singleton

Cephalic

TPUS

DVE

Zimerman et al. [15]

Israel

Prospective cohort

52

43%

57%

29.8 ± 4.23

39.7 ± 1.32

 

Singleton

Cephalic

TLUS

DVE

  1. Primi primigravida, Multi multigravida, y years, MI body mass index, TPUS trans-perineal ultrasound, TLUS trans-labial ultrasound, DVE digital vaginal examination